Skip to main content

Adel KHODAIR

Defense

9, December 2026

CERAG

Sustainable Supply Chain Design in the Context of Industry 4.0: Empirical Validation of the Sixth Bottom Line Framework in the Egyptian Manufacturing Sector

Jury

Paul REAIDY

Université Grenoble Alpes

Thesis Advising

Tarik SAIKOUK Excelia Business School Rapporteur
Gilles PACHÉ Aix-Marseille University Rapporteur
Karine SAMUEL Université Grenoble Alpes Examiner
Mourad MAKACI University of Western Brittany (UBO) Examiner

 

Abstract

Manufacturing firms in developing economies face a compound adoption challenge that existing frameworks do not adequately address. They must integrate Industry 4.0 technologies and satisfy sustainability standards imposed by global supply chain partners at the same time. These pressures operate within fragmented supplier ecosystems, uneven regulatory enforcement and resource constraints that high-income economy frameworks often treat as resolved. The Triple Bottom Line provides a dimensional architecture for sustainability assessment but offers limited guidance on the organisational mechanisms that enable or constrain performance within those dimensions. This thesis develops and empirically validates the Sixth Bottom Line (6BL) Framework, a bidirectional mechanism-level extension of the Triple Bottom Line that maps both the enabling and the constraining forces within each sustainability dimension for sustainable supply chain design in Egyptian Industry 4.0 manufacturing. The research follows an exploratory sequential mixed-methods design across four cumulative studies. The two qualitative studies drew on 38 semi-structured interviews across 17 Egyptian industrial companies. They identified 32 Key Embrace Factors, of which 20 were not found in the reviewed literature, and 24 Key Constraint Factors, of which eight emerged inductively. Social factors account for 37.5 percent of the enablers and environmental factors for 50 percent of the barriers, and many salient constraints reflect weak supplier relationships. The third study surveyed 368 Egyptian manufacturing and supply chain professionals and validated the framework with Covariance-Based Structural Equation Modelling. The model explains 68.4 percent of variance in I4.0/I5.0 compatibility (all six structural paths significant at p<0.001; χ²/df=1.766, CFI=0.947, RMSEA=0.048). Economic Key Embrace Factors carry the strongest positive relationship (β=+0.534, f²=0.285) and Economic Key Constraint Factors the strongest negative one (β=−0.423, f²=0.179), although social enablers are the most numerous and environmental constraints the most frequent. The bidirectional design makes this dominance reversal between qualitative salience and structural influence visible. A significant difference between the Industry 4.0 compatibility mean (4.12) and the Industry 5.0 transposition mean (3.78, p<0.001) reveals a readiness gap that is not purely technological. The fourth study applied a convergence analysis across the three preceding studies to develop a research agenda on human-technology collaboration, trust-based supplier partnerships and employee-driven sustainability innovation as interconnected capability challenges for the Industry 4.0 to Industry 5.0 transition. The main theoretical contribution is the 6BL Framework itself, which tests enabling and constraining mechanisms together within each Triple Bottom Line dimension. In the field data, inadequate communication with suppliers was the constraint practitioners recognised most (82 percent). Resistance to culture change and an ineffective reverse logistics system followed, at 79 percent each. Among social enablers, teamwork and effective implementation teams reached 76 percent. Practitioners cited environmental constraints most often; however, economic constraints had the largest structural impact. A cluster analysis was performed to group respondents into high-readiness (29 percent), transitional (42 percent) and constraint-dominated (29 percent) groups. Since the transitional group fits within the Industry 4.0 paradigm but lacks readiness for Industry 5.0, it should be targeted first by the research agenda. Managerially, the framework provides a validated approach to prioritise initiatives. For policymakers, it suggests that industrial support should build relational and organisational capabilities, since technology investment does not create them on its own.

Date

9, December 2026
Date Update

14h00

Location

CERAG

Published on 15, September 2026

Updated on November 12, 2026